Should I Sign A Record Deal If A Good One Came Along? Why I’d Say Yes

Should I Sign A Record DealAs you may know, I'm a huge fan of independent musicians. In fact, the majority of the advice on this website is based around moving yourself forward without having to rely on others to do you favors. That said, I posted a guide called ‘What are the chances of getting signed to a major record label?' and was shocked by a lot of the responses I got.

While it got a lot of traffic and shares, there was a large amount of people replying along the lines of:

  1. “Record labels can't help you, you can do everything independently now with the internet.”
  2. “Record labels are rip off artists, they take too much of your money,” and
  3. “I don't want a record label, I'd rather stay independent,”

Here was just a couple of bits from the discussion (which was spread out across Twitter, Facebook and email); I genuinely thank you all for getting involved with your views:

Dont need a record label as technology can help musicians market themselves instead

Record labels taking 50 percent of streaming money

Now I'm a strong believer of two things:

  1. Every musician should start out independent and learn how to develop and market themselves.
  2. You should never rely on getting a record deal or wait for a record label to come along and sign you.

Despite the above two things, if a record label approached you with a good deal, I'd never advise you to reject it just to stay independent. I'll explain why below.

But first, if it's your aim to do music professionally, you'll want to check out our free ebook while it's still available:

Free Ebook 5 Steps To A Profitable Youtube Music Career Ebook Sidebar

Free eBook: Discover how real independent musicians like you are making $4,077 - $22,573+ monthly via Youtube, let me know where to send the details:

The ‘Forever Independent' Mentality Of Many Musicians

To be honest, I see why this popular ‘forget record labels' mentality has come about. Not only are there many labels out there who'd do what they can to suck a musician dry (and drop them once they've got all the profits they think they'll make), but they're signing fewer and fewer acts as it becomes a bigger risk for them. So if deals aren't being offered, you're going to work on being an independent musician right?

While I strongly recommend you learn the skills needed to push your music career forward without a record label, I have to make one thing clear:

There are times when a record deal could benefit your music career, so don't count them out – Tweet This.

If you feel like you'll only want to stay independent forever, ask yourself why you feel like this. Is it because you see other people saying it so feel it must be the right thing to do? Is it because some people have had bad experiences with a record label and you don't want the same to happen to you? Or did you personally have a bad experience with a record label?

Lastly, have you approached record labels and they haven't given you a response?

Whatever the case is, you should never count out something that could potentially benefit you just because others have said that it's not a good idea. There are people out there who vocally oppose everything, but it doesn't mean that it's wrong.

So should you sign a record deal? Well, that depends on the deal. If you're offered one which doesn't have terms beneficial to you, of course not. But if you're offered one which gives you a good deal and a lot more exposure than you could have got alone, why not?

Below I'll look at common objections people have against signing a record deal, and what I think the reality is.

Why Record Labels Still Have Their Uses In 2014 And Beyond

Should i sign to a record labelIn response to the above three general objections I see come up time and time again:

1. “Record labels can't help you, you can do everything independently now with the internet.”

My Response: That's simply not true. While it is possible to market yourself independently, the strength of the record label is doing things on a much wider scale. They have established links which they can use to get you exposure, they have industry insights which you probably don't have access to (although that doesn't mean they're always right of course, and you can get many of the same industry insights on this site), and they have a budget that's most likely much bigger than you could invest into your music career alone.

The money thing alone is a big reason to sign a good record deal if you're offered one. How much money do you have to market your music? My guess is no where near as much as they'd be able to spend on you. You need a big budget to reach the masses, so if you don't have that, as a general rule you should expect to reach a lot less people.

2. “Record labels are rip off artists, they take too much of your money,”

My Response: This isn't a hard and fast rule. Yes some record labels will, but it'll all be down to the deal you make with them. That's why it's important to not sign just any deal because it's offered to you, only do one which will benefit you in the long run.

That said, you do need to remember that the label will fork out money on you upfront. You'll get your pay day, and you'll get paid more along the way (different record labels have different conditions for when and how much so you'll have to refer to each deal individually).

Now remember, record labels are a business and provide you with a service. Yes they'll probably take a percentage of your streaming money, but what do you expect? That they'll work for free just for your benefit? No, they need to eat too.

When you enter a record deal you're entering a partnership. You all work to get all of you money. It's not just you anymore, you're something more. And as such, you need to share the winnings among you.

Have you ever heard of a traditional book company not taking a cut of the money they help make? No, they take a percentage and so does the book writer. Even in digital markets like Amazon's Kindle store, Amazon takes a percentage of all your sales. Why wouldn't they, you're using their tools to make money. With them you can potentially get rich, but without them your job would be a lot harder. So you're basically paying for their services and better reach.

3. “I don't want a record label, I'd rather stay independent,”

My Response: I'd have to ask you why this is? Is it because everyone else is saying it, or is there a real reason? As I said, there are rip off deals out there, and there are very good ones. Don't count out the latter because you've been rejected by record labels in the past, or based on other stories you're heard floating round on the internet. If you're offered a good deal which has your best interests at heart, it'd probably be a good idea to accept it.


While it's important to never rely on getting record deal, if a good one comes along some time in future, it could be a mistake to completely dismiss it. Getting signed can still be beneficial when it's the right deal as record labels can fund you and use their links to get you in places you wouldn't have got otherwise. So while you shouldn't chase a deal down, keep an open mind if one is ever offered.

P.S. Remember though, none of what you've learned will matter if you don't know how to get your music out there and earn from it. Want to learn how to do that? Then get our free ‘5 Steps To Profitable Youtube Music Career' ebook emailed directly to you!

Similar Posts


  1. “The future of music income is streaming”: I hope not, because the income from streaming when compared with other sales – CD/download, etc, is abysmal! If any middle-men siphon off your streaming income then both you and the middle-men will be very poor financially. Even if they don’t, and you rely on income from streaming only, you’ll never be well off.

    Posting you tube videos and submitting to Reverb Nation is hardly going to get you into mainstream now is it? Film-sync is a great idea however.

    If a recording company signed me and gave me 1/4 mil to produce 4 albums over 2 years for example then it’s only fair that they make their money back + a profit. It’s only if I became a household name and the company made a vast profit that I’d be complaining and asking for a better deal.

    Personally I think getting a good manager who is independent of any record company is probably a reasonable idea; then they can sort it out for you – and the better the deal they can get you the bigger their take-home packet becomes – if you’re paying them on a percentage of gross income.

  2. The future of music income is streaming. You want as few middle men as possible siphoning off your streaming income. You can sign up for Google Play direct with no aggregator middle man. You can post your own Youtube videos, update your own Reverbnation, submit to all the film synch companies, run your own publishing business, book your own tour, learn digital recording, put your music on Spotify, Beats, Google Play, etc., all without a label obstructing your efforts. Many bands break up because the labels will not move at the speed of 2014. Even a good Indie punk rock deal splits the income 50-50 net. The label is not going to do enough to justify their 50%.

  3. On this subject: I have to be honest and say that I started out in the music industry with the intention of getting a record deal; but after not too long I realised I had a hell of a lot to learn, and needed to do one whole lot of maturing as an artist before I could even think about looking for a record deal.

    In short I realised that if anyone did approach me with a view toward such a deal I’d be short-changing them: In essence it would be me who was letting them down rather than vice-versa.

    Don’t get me wrong; I consider myself talented and able; it’s just that if I were to sign a record deal I’d want to be able to have a truly-two-way business-relationship with the company I signed with, rather than expecting them to prop me up and keep me afloat while I remained fairly green around the ears and wasn’t able to pull my weight when/if push comes to shove.

    It is for that reason that I’m happily indie for the time being, and possibly will remain so in the immediately foreseeable future. – Having said that; if the chance of a well-suited deal materialised in the meantime I probably wouldn’t say no to it.

Comments are closed.